Bizet, Gounod, Beethoven
I have long noted that only its principle conductor Eduard Topchjan seems to make the mediocre Armenian Philharmonic sound good. I have suspected, though, that this might be because he does not schedule good guest conductors. So tonight I got to hear what would happen if a truly excellent guest conductor took the podium: Pavel Kogan, whom I have seen at the helm of his Moscow State Symphony Orchestra, came to Yerevan.
The orchestra responded beautifully to him. Even the normally-creeky strings produced full and nuanced tones. Although not everyone always managed to play together, they still did far better than they normally do under guest conductors.
The concert opened with the suite #1 from Bizet’s incidental music to L’Arlésienne, in a reading which emphasized the music’s often-hidden peculiar inner harmonies and the melodrama sufficient to remember that Bizet wrote the music to augment a drama.
In contrast, the ballet music from Gounod’s Faust was far less dramatic, because it never belonged in the opera to begin with. Gounod had interpolated it into the opera only to fulfill the Paris Opera’s absurd ballet requirement. So while the music did not portray drama, it still needed to dance, and Kogan had the orchestra dancing appropriately.
After the intermission came Beethoven’s Fourth Symphony. Although not programmatic, this symphony has great drama like all Beethoven symphonies, albeit more subtle. Kogan knew how to draw out the drama that, when hidden, makes this symphony not well-understood. The symphony, which starts slowly and quietly, springs to life in a way a mediocre orchestra might not manage. This one managed tonight.
Only a very small audience showed up, but everyone knew what they had heard. So did the orchestra. Smiles all around and a standing ovation for Kogan from audience and orchestra.