Sibelius, Nielsen, Tschaikowsky
While in Vienna to grab a few things before flying to the US, since I was leaving from Salzburg, I decided to grab a concert.
I have finally heard a piece by Carl Nielsen that I actually liked. Nielsen took a ride over the Alps on a new-fangled automobile which apparently inspired him to write a flute concerto in a hurry. Probably since there are so few flute concerti in the modern repertory, this allowed him more originality than trying to write more standard repertory, at which he usually took his time to produce spectacularly dull results. This work had a degree of whimsy, with juxtaposed sounds – flute with several reeds, flute with tympani, and – most rewardingly – flute with trombone. Marina Piccinini performed the solos, taking a little time to find her tone but once she got there she performed with warmth. The Vienna Symphony Orchestra under Jukka-Pekka Saraste gave her excellent balance and support.
The concert had opened rather more prosaically, with incidental music by Sibelius to Maurice Maeterlinck’s play Pelleas and Melisande. The Sibelius incidental music for this play is rarely performed (particularly in contrast with that by Fauré or Schoenberg) – apparently for good reason, as it is not one of his better efforts. The problem came in that the music was too short and detached to ever fully capture the drama. Sibelius actually set nine pieces to music, of which Saraste picked three (At the Castle Gate, Intermezzo, and Melisande’s Death) – maybe they would have been better served if left in the context of all nine.
For the second half of the concert, Saraste and the Symphoniker gave a spirited reading of Tschaikowsky’s Fourth Symphony. The brass sounded out the fate motive, and spent the rest of the symphony ambitiously trying to overcome that fate, while the rest of the orchestra resigned itself to melancholy. While the final chords echoed triumpantly over the Russian dancing, this reading gave a more anguished triumph. The Symphoniker sounds great, although Saraste is a tad wooden, fully proficient and getting the tone right, but not as dynamic as he could be.