Schoenberg, Tschaikowsky, Mussorgsky
Zubin Mehta, recovering from knee surgery, conducted the Israel Philharmonic tonight in Salzburg’s Large Festival House while sitting down. He received major applause for the effort, and for his genuine popularity. Unfortunately, the handicap resulted in a concert that resembled one of his misses that came all-to-frequently for much of his otherwise charismatic career.
The Israel Philharmonic demonstrated real virtuosity across all of its lines, one instrumentalist finer than the other. They played well together. So the problem came in interpretation, and possibly a lack of inspiration.
Two works by Schoenberg took up the first hour of the concert:Verklärte Nacht and the Chamber Symphony #1. The first work, for a string chamber orchestra, can be quite sensuous, an individual work but still fully tonal. Not tonight, as it dragged from the beginning and the night felt like it never ended. The Chamber Symphony #1, for 15 instruments, already shows Schoenberg begin to break down traditional tonality. This imaginative work requires much expert playing, which we got. But after ten minutes tonight, Mehta ceased to say anything new, leaving the audience to just wait for this to pass.
After the intermission came Tschaikowsky’s Sixth. This interpretation featured more excellent instrumentalism, yet somehow managed to both lack dancing in Tschaikowsky’s lush swinging orchestrations, and also miss the morbid foretelling of the composer’s own death days after the Symphony’s premiere. This version tonight just dragged.
Mehta managed to stay on his feet during the encore, the prelude to Khovanshchina by Mussorgsky, and here we received more drama in the reading. It’s hard to criticize the conductor, who could have rightfully canceled, but that’s what we got. He’s personally popular for a reason. But at least we did get to hear the Israel Philharmonic, itself worth the price of a ticket.