Schumann, Bach, Bruckner
The Mozarteum Orchestra launched its Sunday matinee series for 2015-16 this morning in Salzburg’s Large Festival House with some known but lesser-played, almost experimental, music from the middle of the 19th Century.
Schumann’s “Overture, Scherzo, and Finale” (a rather clunky title after he rejected more logical ones) opened the program. Although perfectly pleasant, this work suffered from a lack of a coherent concept. Schumann revised it many times for more than a decade after its premiere, but does not seem to have ever rectified its main weakness. With an opening almost foretelling Tschaikowsky’s opening to Yevgeny Onyegin (composed a few decades later), Schumann backpedalled into a post-Mozartian muddle before reaching a Bach-like fugue which culminated in a brass chorale almost predicting Bruckner. Where was Schumann going with all of this?
If he was going towards Bruckner, we did have a chance to find out later in the concert. But before we got there, German cellist Jan Vogler came out to slog through Schumann’s Cello Concerto. Again, Schumann produced a perfectly pleasant work which did not say anything. Vogler’s dry tone easily filled the large hall, but nevertheless came out somewhat subdued rather than expansive. When the orchestra stood down and Vogler gave a Bach saraband as an encore, the cellist confirmed the impression. An accomplished musician who formerly filled the first chair of the Dresden Staatskapelle, Vogler’s playing did not lack quality, just dynamism. Perhaps he should return to orchestral playing rather than a solo career.
After the break came Bruckner’s 2nd Symphony, logically resuming where the first Schumann work at the start of the concert had left off. Although Bruckner wrote this piece when he was nearly fifty, it is in many ways a young work as he started writing orchestral music so late. Bruckner never dedicated this symphony, so he offered it to Wagner at the same time as he showed the German composer his 3rd Symphony – Wagner wisely preferred the dedication of the latter, more-mature work. The 2nd could have used some intelligent editing to tighten the phrases. Bruckner did produce several versions over the years, but these did not resolve its underlying wordiness.
A driven performance can overcome these defects. Ivor Bolton, the Mozarteum Orchestra’s music director, did not accomplish this, allowing some of the longer passages to drag. The orchestra, although falling out of synch now and then, sounded strong and in good health. Schumann and Bruckner, in these readings, maybe less so. And while I know from other performances that the Bruckner 2nd can be salvaged, the verdict remains out on these lesser Schumann works.