Stravinsky, Schwertsik, Lindberg, Gruber
This month’s Sunday morning subscription concert of the Mozarteum Orchestra featured a decidedly contemporary selection. The composer HK Gruber conducted and introduced each work – a guided tour of the scores, as it were.
The concert opened with something relatively traditional: Four Norwegian Impressions by Igor Stravinsky, written for a film to portray the German occupation of Norway during the Second World War. As Gruber pointed out, the music was not especially martial nor really Norwegian – mostly it was Stravinsky. These short little-heard pieces were fine music if nothing special – from Stravinsky’s “weak period,” but Gruber said he wished he could write as well as Stravinsky in his “weak period.”
The remaining works on the program were by still-living composers. Some tone poems followed by Kurt Schwertsik, from his multi-year cycle Earthly Sounds – from which Gruber selected Five Nature Pieces (Wind, Thunder, Rain, Water, Birds) composed in 1984 and With the Giant Boots composed in 1991. Schwertsik was apparently driven out of his German compositional school for daring to write tonal music. These were not old-fashioned, just tonal, and relied to a great extent on special effects in the heavily enlarged percussion section. The Five Nature Pieces, all short, ended up being more gimmick than substance – pleasant enough music, but without the special effects there was not much there. The piece With the Giant Boots was much longer, which actually meant that Schwertsik had sufficient time to do development in the orchestra, making this a much more satisfying work. Schwertsik himself came on stage for a long bow and warm applause.
After the intermission came the Clarinet Concerto by Magnus Lindberg, composed in 2002. Of all the works on this morning’s program, this probably succeeded the most. It was also tonal, but mixed a range of styles and approaches (and according to Gruber, Lindberg is fond of drastic tempo changes and explored some with us before the piece began). This may have been the music of George Gershwin if he had lived until 2000 – and had been born in post-Sibelian Finland. The young British clarinetist Mark Simpson demonstrated all the different skillsets required to pull off the solo parts.
For the last work of the morning, Gruber introduced his own 2002 composition, Dancing in the Dark. Gruber sees himself as the heir of the Viennese musical tradition, so his music harks back to previous eras while taking new directions. But this mix of styles and reliance on special effects gets a bit tiresome. So while nothing was quite wrong with this work, there was no commonality and it never seemed to go anywhere even as it did not quite sit still either. Maybe if it had come earlier in the concert, or as part of a concert not entirely dedicated to this type of music, it may have fared better just by being original. Coming at the end today, it simply got lost.
Entertaining curiosities with enlightening presentation – for that we have Gruber to thank. Other than the Lindberg, I am not sure I need to hear these works again.