Prokofiev, Tschaikowsky, JS Bach, Rachmaninov
The Berlin Konzerthausorchester, house orchestra of that (over-rated) concert hall and one of the successors of the old Berlin Symphony Orchestra, a once-good orchestra in former East Berlin, has come to Salzburg for a three-day set.
The band was never in a class with the Berlin Philharmonic in West Berlin, but was established by the communists as a cross-town rival and was formerly rather respectable musically. I am aware that it split at some point, with one successor orchestra keeping the name and the other one keeping the venue (hence changing its name to match the venue). What I do not know is if that split had any connection to the precipitous drop in quality. The original band made numerous high-quality recordings that gave it a global profile, and then at some point the orchestra seems to have faded completely from sight (they did come to Salzburg about five years ago, so I got to hear them then too – but in my only visit to Berlin a few years ago, I heard not this orchestra but rather the Philadelphia Orchestra on the stage of the Berlin Konzerthaus.)
One reason that the orchestra is globally much lower profile these days, of course, is that it just is not up to the level (I have not heard the orchestra that retained the “Symphony” name, but have no reason to believe it is any better). The Berlin Konzerthausorchester is not actually a bad orchestra (I do hear worse in my frequent concert-going), but I score it down because I try to rate orchestras based on their supposed level – I would certainly not criticize a student orchestra for failing to meet the standards of the Vienna Philharmonic, for example. But given the history of where this orchestra once was, I do think it is fair to treat it as though the expectation is its former standard.
This orchestra performs reasonably well technically, but lacks passion for music (I noticed that when they were here in 2015, so it’s endemic). Well, maybe actually the woodwinds showed some passion this evening, but that was unfortunate since they really were not all that good, hitting the notes (or most of them) but producing a strained and un-lyrical tone. The large string section played smoothly but mechanically. The brass was acceptable. Actually, the horn section was pretty good, and the percussionists seemed to enjoy themselves.
Dmitri Katayenko took the podium this evening (thankfully: the orchestra’s music director is actually the tedious Christoph Eschenbach, although possibly Eschenbach and the Berlin Konzerthausorchester might be meant for each other). Kitayenko is good, but only had so much to work with given this orchestra. The main piece, after the intermission, was Rachmaninov‘s Symphony #2 – indeed, I first heard this symphony on an old Melodiya LP with Kitayenko conducting the Moscow Philharmonic (which he led in Soviet days), and it was that recording that made me an instant fan of this work. Kitayenko still understands this symphony and crafted it well from the podium. The orchestra was proficient enough to follow, but not proficient enough to create the full mood or mystery. There were flashes – particularly when the horns had something to say, as well as much of the final movement. But more feeling from the orchestra would have helped.
The first half of the concert opened with excerpts from Romeo and Juliet by Prokofiev. By selecting a handful of spicier numbers, Kitayenko did manage to rouse the orchestra partly.
The star of the evening, however, was the soloist, the 25-year-old Russian cellist Anastasia Kobekina. She produced a gorgeous dark full sound and had a real personality. At moments I thought I could hear traces of the lyricism of Steven Isserlis or the warmth of Mischa Maisky. She is definitely someone to look out for in the future, with a promising career ahead (actually well underway – she started touring young – but as she matures I’m convinced she’ll get even better). She joined the orchestra for Tschaikowsky‘s Variations on a Rococo Theme, which is not actually a particularly good work. It starts out with a theme derivative of Mozart and then doesn’t take it anywhere interesting. But Kobekina outshone the entire orchestra – she was going places. And she followed this with a JS Bach work for solo cello – far more elaborate than what Tschaikowsky produced, with its intellectual mathematical structures. And it was nice to enjoy Kobekina’s performance without an orchestra.